Manuscript Critique

Affordable Book Editing Since 1995:
Expert Manuscript Editor

The highest-priced book editing isn’t always the best. Michael Garrett, a globally recognized manuscript editor and Stephen King’s first editor/publisher, offers professional and affordable book editing services.

Types of Book Editing Services

There are two main categories of editorial services: those with commercial experience and those without. Unfortunately, many inexperienced editors dominate online searches through paid placements, flashy websites, and enticing sample edits. True professional editors, however, rely on their reputation and expertise rather than marketing gimmicks.

Choosing an Experienced
Book Editor

Manuscript editing expert Michael Garrett, a seasoned editor with over 2,000 manuscripts edited, has delivered high-quality manuscript edits since 1995 without the high-end price tag.

Prepare Your Manuscript For Book Editing

Before hiring a manuscript editor, take steps to refine your manuscript to make the editorial process more effective and affordable:

Use Editing Software for Basic Errors:

Grammarly: Helps with grammar, punctuation, and readability
ProWritingAid: Enhances style and structure while detecting inconsistencies
Hemingway Editor: Highlights overly complex sentences for better clarity

Note: Automated tools are helpful but cannot replace a professional editor, who addresses deeper issues like pacing, character development, and plot consistency.

Gather Feedback from Beta Readers:

Beta readers or critique groups can provide valuable feedback. However, be cautious— most beta readers lack professional expertise, leading to misguided advice.

Finding Affordable Book Editing Services
Without Sacrificing Quality

Search for Genre-Specific Book Editors

A professional editor experienced in your genre understands reader expectations and publishing standards. Always review their portfolio, testimonials, and past work before hiring.

Consider Freelance Book Editors

Freelance book editors often offer competitive rates without compromising quality. Look beyond mainstream platforms like Reedsy and Fiverr to find independent professionals with proven experience.

Look Beyond the First Page of Search Results

Search engines prioritize paid placements, not necessarily the best editors. Reading "Don't Trust Online Searches!" can help you make an informed decision.

Beware of Sample Edits

While sample edits may seem useful, they rarely showcase an editor’s ability to improve deeper manuscript issues like plot structure and character arcs.

Fact: Sample edits are worth what they cost—nothing.

Ask for Recommendations

Join writing communities on Facebook (e.g., The Write Life Community), Reddit (r/writing), or critique groups to get trusted referrals for editorial services.

Watch for Overly Flattering Praise

Some editors will say anything to secure your business. A truly professional editor will provide honest, constructive feedback and won’t make unrealistic promises.

Ignore "Best Editors" Lists

“Best Editors” or “Top 10 Editors” lists are misleading and based on paid placements rather than merit. For the truth about these rankings, read "Best Book Editors? Says Who?"

Compare Editing Rates

Professional editorial fees are typically charged per word, page, or hour. Average rates range between $0.01 (100,000 word manuscript equals $1,000) and $0.06 per word (100,000 word manuscript equals $6,000).

Michael Garrett’s rate: $0.025 per word (two-and-a-half cents)

Example: A 100,000-word manuscript would cost $2,500

Warning: If an editorial rate seems too low, it may indicate inexperience or hidden costs. Always request a clear, upfront quote and avoid open-ended hourly agreements.

For more insight, read "The World's Worst Book Editors!"

Evaluating an Editor’s Credentials and Experience

Why Industry Experience Matters

Editors who have worked with major publishers understand what it takes to be published successfully. An inexperienced editor can do more harm than good, potentially damaging your writing career.

Why Published Authors Make Better Editors

Editors who have successfully self-published have unique insights into the editorial process. They know what works—and what doesn’t—in today’s competitive publishing market.

Communication Matters in
Book Editing

Your Editor Should Be Accessible

If an editor is evasive or difficult to reach before hiring, expect the same during the editing process. Avoid large editorial platforms that prevent direct contact with your editor.

Your Editor Should Respect Your Creative Voice

A professional editor provides expert guidance but never insists on changes. The final revision decisions should always be yours.

Get Professional Book Editing at an Affordable Price!

By researching thoroughly, avoiding scams, and choosing expertise over marketing hype, you can secure affordable, high-quality editing without breaking the bank. Use common sense, and don’t fall for unrealistic promises.

Work with a top manuscript editor today!

I will forever be grateful to Michael Garrett for making me a better writer.

-- Lisa Kay Presley via WritersDigest.com

I learned more from your advice than from all of the books
I've read and the courses I took at Gotham Writers' Workshop.

-- Jack Trandahl

My agent called to tell me we received an offer for a three-book deal from Penguin.
Thank you for all the knowledge you passed on to me. I learned so much from you.

-- Cecy Robson, author of Flame and Promise

More unsolicited testimonials

Affordable book editing is available if you
take the time to search for it.

This site is listed on webwiki.